Redheads Are Tinting Their Own Eyebrows with Just For Men Dye: I Did It & This Is My Honest Review

Updated: November 2nd, 2023

Disclaimer: The How to be a Redhead team has not tested this product as redhead-approved. This article is the true opinion of the author.

Like most redheads, I have very light blonde eyebrows and eyelashes. For a long time, it felt like redhead brow products just didn’t exist, or they were never the right shade. In 2016 I started tinting my eyebrows with Just for Men Beard Dye. I tried several shades of brown and found the shade “Blonde” gave me a pretty-nice-natural-looking color.

I always wished there was a tint that had more of a red tone to it, and recently Just for Men launched a new color called “Light Red Brown”. Of course, I ordered it immediately and was so excited for my next tinting.

This is when things took a turn…

This shade applied just like all the rest, and I let it sit for my normal 3 minutes (the package says 10, but for brows, I always go for less). When I wiped off the dye, my brows looked darker but good at first glance. They were a little darker than the shade I had been using and there was a red tint to it.

Many don’t know beard dye continues to darken over the next few hours after application. I had never seen much of a difference with the “Blonde” shade, but the new “Light Red Brown” shade darkened A TON in the hours to come. By the next day my brows looked almost black. They did have a subtle red hint but boy, oh-boy. They were dark.

They did lighten up a little over the next week as they always do. I may have hurried the process along by applying some clarifying shampoo to my brows once a day for a few days, but it took almost a week and a half for my brows to be the color I wanted.

So, in my honest review? The shade may not be good for all redheads. I may try it again and leave the dye on for maybe just a minute, but I think I will stick to using “Blonde” and will add in a little more red/coverage with products like Finally Have Brows when I need it.

Have you tried this trend? Did you get a same result?

Looking for ‘redhead-friendly’ brow products? Look no further!

Finally Have Brows

Redheads can finally have brow products meant for them! We started off with the Finally Have Brows Longwearing Eyebrow Gel and it’s still our bestselling product. Since its release, the product has gone viral on social media and we’ve added Finally Have Brows Volumizing + Finally Have Brows Ultra Fine pencil to the line.

What’s next for Finally Have Brows?

AVAILABLE NOW: Finally Have Brows Clear Brow Gel. It’s best for redheads who want to embrace their natural brow color but desire a fuller/more even look. Tip: This product can also be applied after using Finally Have Brows gels or pencil in Universal Red.