BOGO: BUY FINALLY GLOSSY 
Every week, we put out a call for your redhead questions. This gives you a chance to get advice or input from our team of redheads. From beauty and fashion to lifestyle, redheads are in a unique boat, and we want to help make this community a place where you can turn for all your redhead needs.
This week, we’re answering the question: “Should redheads wear brown mascara?” A redhead on social media shared how a friend suggested that brown mascara might be more flattering, but they weren’t sure what color to rock with their red hair. For most redheads, mascara is an integral part of their makeup routines. Light-colored eyelashes can make them seem invisible, but mascara can help define and lengthen the lashes.
Brown vs. black mascara
The two most common mascara colors are black and brown. These shades can be found in almost any drugstore nationwide and are standard for mascara brands. For redheads, the decision between the two might be confusing. Neither black nor brown matches our hair, so which one do we choose? The redhead who wrote in was told that brown may be more flattering on them, and that can be true! Redheads often have a unique complexion and hair color that can be better enhanced with brown mascara instead of black. Here’s why brown mascara might be an excellent choice for you:
- Subtle Contrast: Brown mascara offers a softer contrast against red hair and fair skin compared to the starkness of black. This can create a more natural, harmonious look that complements the warmth of red hair.
- Warmth and Depth: Brown mascara tends to blend well with the warm tones of red hair, creating a more cohesive and flattering appearance. It can add depth to your lashes without overwhelming your features.
- Natural Look: Brown mascara can be a great option for a more understated or natural makeup look. It enhances your lashes without being too bold or dramatic.
- Highlighting Natural Color: Brown mascara can highlight and complement the natural hues in red hair, allowing for a more balanced and complementary look.
- Daytime Wear: Brown mascara can be more appropriate and less intense for daytime or casual looks than black. It’s also great for a more relaxed, everyday makeup routine.
Brown is usually much softer and more natural-looking for those with red hair and fair features. That being said, if you love wearing black mascara, you don’t have to wear brown. It’s all about personal preference! If you are considering opting for a brown shade, you have options.
How redheads can choose their shade:
For years, the only brown mascara options were brown-black and standard brown. These shades are usually relatively dark and more on the cool-toned side of the color spectrum. Now, redheads have their own mascara, which gives you more options. Finally Have Lashes® redhead mascara comes in five shades.
Our mascara line also comes in two different brush shapes. Want to learn more? Redhead Mascara Brushes: A Guide To The Different Shapes In Our Line
RED-Y for Lashes, Perfectly Auburn: Our Perfectly Auburn shade is a true ginger color and an excellent match for natural-looking lashes. It is designed to match your red hair and give you that “no makeup makeup” look. The custom shade is timeless, leaving you wondering, “Where has this been my whole life?”
RED-Y for Lashes, Perfectly Auburn
Fall In Love With Your Red Hair, Perfectly Chestnut: Our Perfectly Chestnut shade is slightly darker and more of a warm medium brown tone. This shade is inspired by the beauty of autumn. Fall in love with your red hair when you rock this custom chestnut shade. It’s deeper than Perfectly Auburn but lighter than Perfectly Brown.
Fall In Love With Your Red Hair, Perfectly Chestnut
Brown with a Splash of Red, Perfectly Brown: This shade is designed to be a “true brown” shade, so we added a splash of red to complement redheads. It’s a rouge-inspired brown that is lighter than a traditional black but dark enough to give your eyes a pop.
Brown with a Splash of Red, Perfectly Brown
Redhead Royalty®, Perfectly Plum: We also have Perfectly Plum, a rich berry purple with red undertones that is ultra-flattering and unique! This shade is designed to make you feel like true Redhead Royalty®. The custom berry shade is rich, subtle, and regal.
Redhead Royalty®, Perfectly Plum
A Full 180, Perfectly Black: This is for redheads who love black mascara. The clean formula is sensitive-friendly, vegan, and cruelty-free.
Pairing your mascara with your look
With our various shades of mascara, redheads can find their perfect look for any occasion. Auburn and chestnut will provide the right amount of color to your light lashes for a more natural look. For more definition but an everyday wear, brown blends seamlessly with our fair skin tone and warm hair color. Plum provides a perfect pop of color to make your lashes stand out, and black is perfect for a tried-and-true makeup look. No matter what shade, redheads can rock any shade of mascara.
Want your redhead question answered? Find us @howtobearedhead on Instagram and Facebook, and look for the Ask a Redhead question box.
Rock it like a Redhead!
RELATED POSTS
READ: TikTok Is Obsessed With Brown Mascara (And Our Fave Is…)
READ: Ask a Redhead: Any Tips and Tricks for Blonde Eyelashes?
